Avoid Temp Staffing Dilemmas

March 21, 2012

Twenty years of managing people and dealing with HR issues for number of large IT organizations prepared me surprisingly well for my first-hand work in the front end of a two-doctor dental office. The lessons learned carry over to address some of the challenges of running a successful practice. Prime among these challenges is the never-ending quest to fill vacant office positions. Complicating this issue is the increasing reliance on part-time and temporary help, and the difficulty in identifying truly qualified candidates.

Twenty years of managing people and dealing with HR issues for number of large IT organizations prepared me surprisingly well for my first-hand work in the front end of a two-doctor dental office. The lessons learned carry over to address some of the challenges of running a successful practice.

Prime among these challenges is the never-ending quest to fill vacant office positions. Complicating this issue is the increasing reliance on part-time and temporary help, and the difficulty in identifying truly qualified candidates.

“In six short years I’ve had employees quit suddenly, not even show up, and embezzle funds, but it happens to all dentists I talk to,” says Mojan Safavi, DDS who practices in McKinney, TX. “My colleagues and I struggle with these issues on a regular basis, hoping to find a solution so our practices aren’t hijacked by our staff.”

Dr. Safavi is just one of the dentists I have met with that have similar experiences. However, by applying successful strategies from the corporate world and harnessing the power of the Internet, practitioners can regain control of their office to prevent devastating drops in productivity caused by employee vacancies.

Develop a written process that anyone can follow

One thing I’ve noticed in the dental industry, especially in smaller offices, is too great a reliance on individuals.

“I’ve had days where I’m fully booked with patients, but five minutes before the day begins, the dental assistant calls in sick,” says Safavi. “What do you do? Without them, it’s hard to do procedures like cement veneers. You aren’t even sure where some of the dental products are, so you have to cancel most of your patients. All that potential income vanishes.”

The absence of a hygienist proves equally as costly.

“For the lack of a hygienist the doctor can lose around $20,000 to 30,000 a month,” says Fariba Dadgostar, general manager for the Dossett Dental chain located in the greater Dallas, TX, area. “A delay in securing a dental-insurance specialist can be equally as financially devastating.”

In contrast, large organizations usually don’t rely on individuals. Instead, there are processes in place. Everyone’s job is well documented. We can replace a person, and with only a minor hiccup, continue with that work as before. So I would advise office owners to have a strategy in place where employees document the processes they utilize to perform their jobs. It should be written so that anyone can follow those steps.

Utilize technology to find qualified employees

The ability to identify fill-in employees that meet the exigent employment needs of a successful dental office can help practitioners concentrate on the more profitable process of filling carries rather than filling job positions. Yet, to my amazement, many dentists still resort to calling up traditional temporary agencies when they need help.

“I used to call a temporary agency to send me people who were supposed to be the best,” recalls Safavi. “But they’d come to my office without knowing how to take film X-rays, let alone digital. Or, in the case of a front office person, they hadn’t a clue about walkout process using our software or deal with insurance issues. The temp worker might argue, ‘Well, I used to work the insurance desk at a podiatrist’s office.’ A lot of good that does me!”

I’ve observed two different types of temporary workers: those that can’t keep a permanent job because no one wants them around for more than a week; and solid people who have other things to do with the rest of their time and just like to work occasionally. One way to separate the two and avoid surprises is to find a website that incorporates a rating system to assess qualifications before you hire the worker.

DentalSpots.com, for one, has built into its portal a means to allow dentists or office managers to rate recently-acquired employees that other offices can review to determine a good hire. A five-star rating system is used, along with comments by the reviewing doctor. While seemingly a benefit only to employers, such practices also act as a benefit for well-performing employees in their job searches. They get recognized for the good work they do.

Keep staff levels at a necessary minimum

Another problem I’ve come to see is that, despite the downturn in the economy that has depressed the patient load of many dentists, some still maintain a bloated headcount in hopes that things will pick up again. They might employ two back office assistants and two front office personnel, when the office really only needs one of each. This folly can waste thousands of dollars each month.

A better strategy consists of holding onto a solid core of permanent employees, and relying on temporary workers only when needed.

If, for example, you realize that you’re routinely fully-booked on Tuesdays, you should be able to quickly hook-up with a temporary worker for that one day. Use the temporary person for the four days in a given month that you might get swamped, and avoid the expense of keeping an additional person on the payroll for thirty days. Some job-board sites facilitate such match-ups where a dental employee may actually post their preference to only work on certain days.

Keep acquisition costs to a minimum

Given the inexpensive resources found on the Internet, it is now hard to justify calling on costly brick and mortar temporary agencies.

“The agencies I used in the past would charge me charge me $30 to $50 a day as their cut,” says Safavi. “Even worse, the hourly pay the temp’ gets is usually more expensive than what your own help is getting. Additionally, if the agency sends you someone who is very skilled, and you want to hire them permanently, you have to pay as much as $2,000 to the agency for that privilege.”

From what I’ve seen in the corporate world, buyers have learned to reduce the impact of the middle man as much as possible. Similarly, using a website that allows you to screen prospective employees for free, paying a nominal fee only when you are interested in interviewing the person, and then nothing else if you do hire them, can literally save thousands.(We allow them to see only certain information and we only charge them when they confirm which means they are hiring the temp worker for that opening. This is usually temp position for a day and not a permanent hire)

“Using the Dental Spots site, we have little to lose because they only charge us when we find someone we want,” notes Dossett Dental’s Dadgostar. “Even at that, the fee is only ten dollars.”

Utilize local talent

In some large organizations, I’ve seen where the HR department is given a mandate to not hire anyone, no matter how qualified, that lives beyond a defined distance from the jobsite. Dentists can take a page from this book.

“Once, a temp agency sent us a hygienist that we fell in love with; she was fantastic,” says Safavi. “We hired her, but after two months she quit because she decided it was too far to drive.”

A practitioner is well advised to utilize a website that facilitates the hiring of help who are proximate to the practice location. Some of the best offer a map for easy assessment of the distance involved. At some sites, employees can even declare, in advance, how far they are willing to drive, so the person doing the hiring can quickly rule them in or out.

Develop a sense of community with your potential pool of employee candidates

As we all know, vacancies pop up at a moment’s notice. To fill these spots on equally short notice, take proactive steps to stay in touch with qualified workers who you can call on immediately.

Take advantage of dental-industry specific websites that can double as a social networking site. Limiting that on-line community to dental practitioners and their employees makes everything all the more personal, in contrast to job-aggregation sites like CareerBuilder.com, etc.”

“Let’s say a Frisco, Texas, hygienist wants to relocate to San Francisco, California. Within that one portal she can research the offices in the new city to find out which practices share her sensibilities in terms of working conditions and hours, and then with one click she can send off her resume and a cover letter, even if a job hasn’t been posted yet. Doctors immediately receive notification of this “newbie” in town. In this sense, the site makes it easy for dental professionals to get to know each other not just by posting jobs, but by building relationships.”

There really are a lot of good resources out there.  All you really need to do is to connect to them.

For more information, contact: DentalSpots.com at 972-325-4295; info@DentalSpots.com or www.DentalSpots.com